Dufferin County

Living in Shelburne, OntarioHomes for Sale & Local Guide

A local's guide to buying a home in Shelburne, one of Dufferin County's fastest-growing towns, plus every Shelburne listing updated every 15 minutes.

~9,000Population
20 minTo Orangeville
~1 hr 30To downtown Toronto
Hwy 10 & 89Main routes

Why People Move to Shelburne

Shelburne sits where Highways 10 and 89 meet, about 20 minutes north of Orangeville. Its population of roughly 9,000 has grown quickly over the last decade as new subdivisions brought in young families and first-time buyers looking for more house for their money. You get a friendly small-town main street, newer homes with garages and yards, and open farm country all around, with Orangeville's hospital and big-box shopping a short drive south.

Value for your money

Newer detached homes and townhomes in Shelburne often cost less than similar homes in Orangeville or Caledon.

Small-town feel

A walkable Main Street with local shops and restaurants, and a long tradition of community events like the annual fiddle contest.

Recreation

The Centre Dufferin Recreation Complex has arenas and a pool, and the town has parks, sports fields and trails.

Country all around

Melancthon, Mulmur and Amaranth surround the town, with farmland, rural properties and the Mulmur hills close by.

Shelburne Neighbourhoods at a Glance

  • Downtown and Main Street: older homes and century character close to shops, the library and community events.
  • Newer subdivisions: large areas built from the 2000s on, mostly on the edges of town, with detached homes, semis and townhomes popular with young families.
  • Starter homes: townhomes and semis are a common first step for buyers moving up from renting or coming from the GTA.
  • Just outside town: Melancthon, Mulmur and Amaranth offer country homes and acreage, often on well and septic.
A red brick century home on a quiet Shelburne street
Local spotlight

Century homes and new builds side by side

Shelburne's older streets near Main Street have classic red brick homes with big porches and mature trees, while the newer subdivisions on the edges of town offer modern layouts and garages. Few towns give you both choices at these prices.

Commuting From Shelburne

Highway 10 runs south to Orangeville in about 20 minutes and continues to Brampton in roughly an hour. Highway 89 heads east toward Alliston and Highway 400. Downtown Toronto is usually around an hour and a half by car. Many Shelburne buyers work in Orangeville, Caledon or Brampton, or work from home part of the week.

New Build or Resale in Shelburne?

Shelburne has a lot of newer housing, so most buyers end up comparing the two. Here's how they usually stack up.

Newer buildResale home
PriceOften a little higher per square footOften better value in a finished neighbourhood
Move-inCan mean waiting on constructionUsually 30 to 90 days
WarrantyTarion warranty coverageNo builder warranty, so a home inspection matters more
NeighbourhoodStreets, parks and trees still filling inMature trees, finished parks and established neighbours
Extra costsClosing adjustments, driveway paving, landscapingUpdates and repairs, depending on age

Every home is different. I'm happy to walk you through the numbers on any listing.

Tips for Buying a Home in Shelburne

  • Compare new and resale. There is a lot of newer housing in Shelburne. A resale home in a finished neighbourhood can be better value than waiting on a new build.
  • Check the builder warranty. For newer homes, ask what is left on the Tarion warranty and whether any items were reported.
  • Look at the drive. If you commute south every day, test the drive at rush hour before you buy. Highway 10 traffic builds near Orangeville.
  • Plan for winter. Shelburne is on high, open ground and gets strong winds and snow drifts. A garage and a good driveway make winter easier.

Shelburne Real Estate FAQ

Is Shelburne a good place to live?

For many young families and first-time buyers, yes. Shelburne offers newer homes at a lower price than much of Dufferin and Peel, a small-town community feel, and Orangeville's hospital and shopping about 20 minutes away.

How far is Shelburne from Orangeville and Toronto?

Shelburne is about 20 minutes north of Orangeville on Highway 10. Brampton is roughly an hour away and downtown Toronto usually around an hour and a half by car.

What county is Shelburne in?

Shelburne is in Dufferin County. Nearby are Orangeville, Mono and the townships of Melancthon, Mulmur and Amaranth.

Can I see every home for sale in Shelburne on this site?

Yes. The Shelburne search shows all MLS listings in Shelburne, updated every 15 minutes. Create a free account to save homes you like.

Thinking About Shelburne?

I work across Dufferin County every day. If you're thinking about buying or selling in Shelburne, I'll give you straight answers about the neighbourhoods, new builds and the market.

Nearby Communities

Photos via Flickr. Main Street and brick home: Dougtone, CC BY-SA 2.0.